Every post in the blog is an original piece of work by the blogger. Do not use the pictures, posts on the blog without the consent of the blogger.

Page copy protected against web site content infringement by CopyscapeCreative Commons License
Aaditya and Me by Aditya Joshi is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivative Works 2.5 India License

Saturday, January 02, 2010

3 idiots - Movie Review

'3 idiots' is undoubtedly my most awaited movie of the year - one of the reasons being the fact that I have loved '5 point someone'.

I have my opinion regarding the current spat between Chetan Bhagat and the makers of 3 idiots. I write this review being impartial w.r.t. that. I have also mentioned my opinion regarding the movie - but have kept it to the end (I mean, a movie is good or not is not dependent on whether it is a copy or not. Because in that case, I should not love many Bollywood movies. :-p )

Rajkumar Hirani works on his superhit formula again - give a mantra to make people happy, have a character which is unconventional/rebellious yet spreads a lot of love and joy around him. In Munnabhai, it was the jaadoo ki jhappi, in 3 idiots it is 'Aal iz well'.

Pre-release, I was hooked to the music of the film - repeatedly heard 'Give me some sunshine' and 'Zoobi doobi'. 'Give me some sunshine' is a number which proves that a guitar and strong lyrics can make a song really successful.

Some comedy scenes in the movie make you roll on the floor laughing - the 'chamatkar' scene being one of the funniest ones. The Ranchhoddas twist takes you by surprise. The climax starts off with a non-hero Sharman running away with a to-wed Kareena from the shaadi ka mandap and that's when you know it's really not going to be very conventional. It only gets better when 'Funsuk Wangdu' comes into the picture!

Aamir Khan is constantly under focus in the film. No wonder people are loving his performance so much. I mean, when you have the limelight on you, you are going to look as fair as a fairy! Nevertheless, Sharman Joshi and Madhavan definitely stand out. Boman Irani's character looks like an extension of the angry school principal from Munnabhai 1 - just that here the 'evility' has been toned down to some extent. I have been an avid fan of Mona Singh and was pleasantly surprised to see her in the film.

The friendship between the three characters which was the soul of the book comes out well in the movie. The movie claims to make a statement about the current education system. It does so to some extent.

MANY jokes from the movie are stale. They are either from cheap SMS forwards or from '5 point someone'. So, they didn't really make me laugh. I could only smile. What were the writers thinking when they copied a joke directly from a television advertisement (where the student puts his paper in a stack of papers after an examination). Chori karo, par kam se kam pakde mat jaao yaar!

By the way, whoever said that '3 idiots' is LOOSELY based on '5 point someone' has horribly mistaken. I do not know what the contract between Chetan Bhagat and the makers of the movie is. So I would not comment on who is right. But, the makers' claim that it is only a loose adaptation is TOTALLY wrong. Several jokes and the key scenes are lifted from the book.


Overall verdict : Both the Munnabhais made me laugh and cry a lot. 3 idiots did not make me cry at all, tickled me in parts. It entertained me nevertheless. Not worth the hype - definitely should make a good watch.


  1. perfect review as usual .....totally agree with you in terms of it not being just 'loosely based' ... definitely a lot of pick up directly from the book shouldnt just be loosely based , but it did make me cry in some parts ....and yes i too didnt laugh to infinity as such its just makes you smile . But overall a good movie .

  2. It is a good movie and does quite well both in terms of pace and delivery, UNTIL the child birth. That is a sheer waste of time, irrelevant and unnecessary. That's where they lost me :)

  3. ahhh...i was expecting it to be interesting....and it was. i mean the blog post, not the movie....:P

    i have been a fan of aamir for a long long time now but tht didnt make me watch the movie for the simple reason tht the promos didnt make me inquisitive enuf....:) i wld rathe watch the dvd of Dil Chahta Hai back to back 3 times :D

  4. hmmm.. Nice review of the movie..
    and you are right.. it has lot of episodes copied directly from the book or as u said the advertisement..
    But still considering few stupid things.. like carrying the old man on scooter and the delivery add up to the negative points.
    But still many jokes were fresh. While considering the comedy movies, the Hera-Pheri, Golmaal (parts 1,2) have large amount of redundant loud comedy.
    But I personally think that Chetan Bhagat books have lot of 'masala' in them already and if copied there is absolutely no need to add anything else..

  5. It's just another CHEAP Bollywood movie utterly lacking originality. Delivering good message is not the only important thing. For an art, it has to be original to be respected.